Claire Richards’s review published on Letterboxd:
Me the whole time trying to figure out if Señor Cienfuegos was really Andy Garcia
Sorry if this is sacrilegious, but I didn't like this that much! I was not expecting greatness, but I was expecting an enjoyable time, and I didn't even get that, besides a few moments (namely Stellan and Colin in the boat). I just...really did Not like any of the songs... like at all?
This movie was just so awkward and cringey I couldn't let myself go and embrace the magic of Mamma Mia.
Lily James though... a goddess!
And did the fountain of Aphrodite explode and completely destroy the hotel or something, why did it look completely different???
Also young Bill was my favorite of the dudes!