Top 50 of All Time

Incredibly subject to change.
Three honorable mentions because they're wonderful trilogies that don't have a best film:
Before Trilogy (Before Sunrise, Before Sunset, Before Midnight)

Lord of the Rings Trilogy

Three Flavors Cornetto Trilogy (Shaun of the Dead, Hot Fuzz, The World's End)

  • Scott Pilgrim vs. the World

    1

  • Fight Club

    2

  • Pan's Labyrinth

    3

  • Solaris

    4

  • Synecdoche, New York

    5

  • Battle Royale

    6

  • The Godfather

    7

  • Spirited Away

    8

  • Grave of the Fireflies

    9

  • Eyes Without a Face

    10

  • Let the Right One In

    11

  • Blindspotting

    12

  • Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

    13

  • High and Low

    14

  • Taxi Driver

    15

  • Ferris Bueller's Day Off

    16

  • City Lights

    17

  • Persepolis

    18

  • There Will Be Blood

    19

  • Strangers on a Train

    20

  • Barry Lyndon

    21

  • Children of Men

    22

  • The Sting

    23

  • Stardust Memories

    24

  • (500) Days of Summer

    25

  • Citizen Kane

    26

  • WALL·E

    27

  • The Prestige

    28

  • About Elly

    29

  • Mr. Nobody

    30

  • Up in the Air

    31

  • Oldboy

    32

  • Barton Fink

    33

  • Mommy

    34

  • Matchstick Men

    35

  • Her

    36

  • The Deer Hunter

    37

  • Halloween

    38

  • The Player

    39

  • Lethal Weapon

    40

  • Into the Wild

    41

  • Peeping Tom

    42

  • Juno

    43

  • Heathers

    44

  • The One I Love

    45

  • Mulholland Drive

    46

  • Gremlins

    47

  • The Darjeeling Limited

    48

  • The Squid and the Whale

    49

  • Perfect Sense

    50