David Punch

List by David Punch Pro

Published Updated

Sort by

Silent Comedians Ranked

A ranked list of every feature-length silent comedy (over 40 minutes in length) starring the three great silent comedy legends: Charlie Chaplin, Buster Keaton, and Harold Lloyd. As with all lists this one is subjective and in no way a claim of definitive ranking. Ranking is subject to change as I continually rewatch and reevaluate films from the list.

Block or Report
  • Sherlock, Jr.

    1

  • Modern Times

    2

  • Safety Last!

    3

  • The Gold Rush

    4

  • The Cameraman

    5

  • The Kid Brother

    6

  • City Lights

    7

  • Dr. Jack

    8

  • Steamboat Bill, Jr.

    9

  • The General

    10

  • For Heaven's Sake

    11

  • The Navigator

    12

  • Why Worry?

    13

  • The Freshman

    14

  • Three Ages

    15

  • Shoulder Arms

    16

  • Spite Marriage

    17

  • Grandma's Boy

    18

  • The Circus

    19

  • Seven Chances

    20

  • Our Hospitality

    21

  • Speedy

    22

  • Hot Water

    23

  • The Kid

    24

  • Girl Shy

    25

  • Go West

    26

  • The Pilgrim

    27

  • Battling Butler

    28

  • A Sailor-Made Man

    29

  • College

    30