DirkH’s review published on Letterboxd:
Part of Dastardly Difficult December: film nr.84
Every country has its dark periods in history, often with filled with war and intolerance. It does not happen that often though that a country turns on itself, fearing a secular belief associated with an enemy far away. McCarthy's witchhunt for communist sympathisers has always been a historical event that has intrigued me. It turned one of the most powerful nations in the world into a paranoia ridden country fueled by intolerance and fear. It shows that the drive of one person can lead to dangers that affect an entire country, ruining many lives in the process.
Clooney provides us with a stunningly accurate slice of history. He documents the fight of legendary newscaster Edward R. Murrow to bring down McCarthy without sensationalism or extreme dramatization. It seems to be more intent on documenting the how and what than the why. This aspect is strengthened by the great use of actual footage. Murrow's tenacity and motivation, however, aren't really explained in great detail, but what is implied is that he feels the need to take a stand as he sees injustice growing around him. It could perhaps have done with a bit more characterization, but what I absolutely loved about Clooney's approach is the nostalgic tribute to the power of great journalism and the potential for greatness of the television medium. This is perhaps explained strongest in Murrow's final speech, which seems relevant today in the growing shallowness of TV news and entertainment.
Paired with Clooney's wonderfully understated direction is Strathairn's carreer best performance. His delivery of the beautifully written monologues is done with conviction and a persuasive confidence. It's the kind of performance that makes a good film great.
Clooney's film is a classically crafted slice of history that has a central performance that is worth the watch alone.