MrMapleSyrupz’s review published on Letterboxd:
I think most of the world agrees Beautiful Girls and Broadway Melody are overlong and unneeded in the overall scheme of the movie, so I'll be taking away the perfect 100 score for this movie. But it will in no way be leaving my top ten favorite movies. It's utterly joyous and never fails to put a smile of my face. Gene Kelly, Donald O'Connor and Debbie Reynolds are perfection and have some of the greatest on screen chemistry ever. Incredible songs and choreography paired with incredible set pieces. Greatest musical of all time.