Orange Warrior’s review published on Letterboxd:
Enjoyed finally watching this, but it didn't Quite make the landing.. Without wanting to sound spoilt, whilst it was all masterfully done, it was very much "Quirky comedy with an Important Message Bingo" and nothing felt uniquely fresh or different... The exception being Waititi's manic imaginary Hitler of course, but that was so heavily trailed in promotional material that it seemed a bit 9ld hat already.
So yes, a soup made of many fine and delicious ingredients that comes out just tasting like pumpkin, which is a disappointment when you want it to be exceptional.